Is Offensive Speech OK on License Plates?
In a recent Supreme Court hearing, the justices heard a case out of Texas involving personalized license plates. The state plate program allows citizens to include images on the plates, and the petitioner in this case desired a Confederate flag. The license bureau denied the request, wanting to keep a symbol that is offensive to many off the state-owned plate. The petitioner argues that this state action is a denial of free speech. Listen to the report at NPR.org linked below and see what you think. Then answer the questions below.
Questions for Completion:
1. What is the state of Texas’s legal argument as to why it can regulate the speech on these plates?
2. List one hypothetical or comparison that a justice offered.
3. How would you decide the case if you were on the Court and why?
After answering questions, check out the Court’s decision.